4 Comments
User's avatar
salience's avatar

See also:

The Tragedy of Tribalism

Russell Brand Interviews Norman Finkelstein about Israel and Palestine.

John Leake

Jan 14, 2024

https://www.thefocalpoints.com/p/the-tragedy-of-tribalism

salience's avatar

"Righteousness has a way of editing its own archives."

I will have to steal that one!

Michelle's avatar

I am seeing this pattern currently appearing in public discourse on the ‘right’, about repealing women’s’ rights to vote (JJ Carrell, Peter Thiel). The argument being that women are too sexualized, masculine, and opinionated. There is no room for facts with thinking like this, just their stated remedy of sending women back to subjugation by silence. Society is a thin veil without further dividing women and men.

salience's avatar

"In-group or out-group. Clean or unclean. With us or against us."

This is very likely an evolutionary heritage from advanced ape societies where it was an advantage, providing group coherence and survival.

https://peterwebster.substack.com/p/tribalism-xenophobia-us-and-them

Tribalism, Xenophobia, Us and Them

Peter Webster

Jun 17, 2022

If indeed, it is "in our genes" it will be exceptionally difficult to overcome both individually and society-wide.

Here we can understand why it was an advantage for advanced ape societies:

Unto Others

The Evolution and Psychology of Unselfish Behavior

Elliott Sober

David Sloan Wilson

Harvard University Press 1998